Friday, April 24, 2009

Getting Incentives Right (and Learning About it in B-School)

This post is directed at first-year MBA students at the David Eccles School of Business. For the rest of you... Maybe you should consider becoming a first-year MBA student at the David Eccles School of Business.

Read this article from yesterday's Wall Street Journal. I don't agree with everything that's written here. I do agree that bad incentives are the central problem that led us into the financial mess. But I don't agree that business schools don't teach students how to think in a structured, careful way about the provision of incentives in modern firms.

Because this is what I do.

I know you didn't see me do any of it in the fall. Unfortunately, that core micro course you took is way too short. Plus there are some basic micro principles (supply/demand/elasticity/etc) that have to be covered. So I don't get to do any incentives stuff there.

But let me tell you what I'm doing in the Fin 6250 elective this fall. I'm teaching essentially the same course I developed and taught for ten years at the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern. At Kellogg, the course was called "Strategy and Organization," and the emphasis was on how you design an organization to achieve strategic objectives. I'm downplaying the strategy angle a bit (but not completely) because I'm in finance department not strategy here. But we're still going to start from the notion that in order to achieve different strategic objectives, you need to change the actions of individual people inside your firm. And individuals' actions in a firm are determined (at least in part) by the organization surrounding those individuals, and the resulting incentives.

That is, we're going to undertake a serious study of the economics of incentives. We're going to use that to develop economic theories of optimal organization. And we're going to link that to ideas from strategy, finance, and accounting.

Economics isn't, of course, the only useful way to think about these issues. But I think it provides a practical and useful perspective, and I'll hope to convince you of it in the fall.

I'm not really that comfortable blowing my own horn. But I've come to the unfortunate realization that marketing oneself is actually sort of important. So here's the hard sell: Kellogg is one of the top management schools in the world, and this elective was one of the most popular elective courses offered there. I picked up a slew of teaching awards there for this course. Students would save their points (electives were allocated using a points-based bidding system) and blow all of them to get into this course. The course is at the leading edge of what economists know about incentives and organization.

Teaching micro to MBAs? I could take it or leave it. Teaching how to analyze incentives and organization using economics? That's what gets me going.

If you think you might run an organization (for-profit or not) in your career --- and if you don't think you might do this, then why are you getting an MBA? --- you should take this course.

It's suitable for Masters of Accounting, and Masters of Finance, and Masters of Public Policy, and ... well, you can see I get excited about this stuff... So look into it.

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Earth Day

It's Earth Day, so I thought I'd liven things up with some concerns about the environmental movement. I know I'm a wet blanket, but economics isn't called the dismal science for nothing.

Before I do this, I'll issue a disclaimer. I'm not a global-warming denier, or an anti-environmentalist. My concerns are more along the lines of questioning whether we're taking the right approaches in trying to change behavior to make it more environmentally friendly. So here goes:

I opened the SL Tribune today to this article. A Dutch scientist has coined the term "water footprint" to capture the notion that water is an input to the production of many of the goods and services that we consume every day. And if we're trying to conserve water, then we can't just be satisfied by turning off the tap. We should also think about reducing our consumption of other goods and services that use a lot of water.

From the article:

A middle-class American woman who eats an average amount of meat consumes 3,245 cubic meters of water each year in her diet, according to the Dutch quick calculator. If the same woman is an ovo-lacto vegetarian (who avoids meat, but does eat eggs and dairy products), her footprint drops to 2,514 cubic meters.
It takes a lot of water to raise livestock, which makes sense although I hadn't really thought about it.

And so what should we do about this? What the "H20 Conserve" folks have done is put together a web site that allows you to compute your water footprint.

This is a fine thing to do, and I'm not criticizing the H20 Conserve people for putting this information out there. More information is better, and it's obviously a huge effort to put this site together.

Is it the best way to conserve this resource?

My answer is no. Why?

One of the problems with this approach is that environmentally committed consumers need to keep enormous mental lists of what products use what resources. We know, for example, that we're supposed to conserve water. And so if you're really serious about conserving water, you need to know what products use a lot of water (so you can reduce use thereof) and what products don't use a lot of water. We also know that we're supposed to reduce carbon. So we need to keep lists of what products use less carbon, and what products don't. The list of environmentally harmful by-products of modern life is long, and the resulting computational burden on the environmentally conscious consumer is large.

There must be a better way, right? And there is.

The better way is to use prices.

For example, let's imagine that we implement a carbon tax. If you emit carbon, you pay. What will this do to the prices of the goods and services we consume? Products that generate substantial carbon emissions will become more expensive to produce. Basic microeconomics says that the prices of these products (to the end user) will rise. Consumer demand will shift --- exactly to the products that don't use a lot of carbon, because prices for these products will stay low! (Which is exactly the consumer behavior we're trying to generate with the "mental lists" approach outlined above!)

Under the "price appropriately" approach, we don't tell consumers "avoid products that use a lot of water, and by the way here's the list". Instead, we tell them "Water is scarce and high-priced as a result. If you want to consume a product that uses a lot of water, you can. But you'll find it's in your own financial best interest to shift consumption to less-water-intensive products."

The "price appropriately" approach has three big benefits over the "mental lists" approach.

Benefit #1: Doesn't rely on public-spiritedness The efficacy of the "mental lists" approach depends on the willingness of people to ignore their own economic interests and instead do what's best for the planet because it's the right thing to do. A lot of people are willing to do this, but not everyone is. If instead we tax environmentally harmful activities, then we won't be relying on public spirit; we'll be aligning self-interest with what's best for the planet.

Benefit #2: Doesn't require mental lists It's hard to be gentle on the planet. You have to do a lot of research into what products use a lot of resources and what products don't. Even for the committed, this can be a big burden.

Benefit #3: Might actually work Did the American people know before the summer of 2008 that consumption of gasoline was environmentally harmful? If so, then why didn't we reduce usage? The fact is that people respond to changes in prices in way that they don't respond to hearing the message "it's really best if you drive less." Yes, gasoline prices rose to frightful levels last summer. But gasoline consumption fell for the first time in years. And it didn't just fall because of people driving less --- it fell because the price increases trickled through the rest of the economy, landing heavily on goods and services that use a lot of gasoline as part of the production process.

So, if you want to fix our planet, fix our markets. And this is why environmentalists should undertake serious study of economics.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Economists and Rush

Turns out Rush fans are disproportionately economists. Even more reason for readers of this blog to dig them.