Thursday, February 26, 2009

Skiing

No blogging this week: I'm going skiing.

Monday, February 23, 2009

Comments/HMOs

A bunch of good comments on my posts lately, and rather than responding in the "comments" area, I thought I'd bring some of them up here. Regarding my post on adverse selection in health insurance, an anonymous reader writes:
So it is apparent that our current costs are known and this points out the flaws in our system. However, a fully socialized health care system can worry people, who think they will not get as good of care. But, wouldn't we paying in what we are now, or roughly the same to a socialized system? And if so and we eliminated the insurance shuffling and paperwork issues (because of this change) wouldn't more of the money we spend go to treating people? What am I missing?

Before I wade into this, let me state that I am not a health-care economist, and I don't know the answer to the question of "what should we do?" But I do know enough to at least see the costs and benefits of various courses of action. This reader is asking about the costs of a single-payer system, so I'll comment on that.

One issue with a socialized, single-payer system is that we're not using the power of competition to keep costs under control.

What happens to automakers who don't contain costs? Consumers stop buying their cars, and they'll be competed out of business (or, perhaps, competed into a massive government bailout... But you get my drift). The key notion is that market competition rewards those firms that figure out ways to keep costs down and still provide goods and services that consumers want.

We'd like the same thing to happen in health care. That is, we'd like someone to be shifting health-care business around to the providers who can offer care that consumers want in a cost minimizing way.

This sounds simple and obvious, but it doesn't work very well in this market. Why not?

One reason is that most of us don't pay the full cost of the health care we receive. Just a quick story about this: I was in Alta's Watson shelter last Friday and walked past the ski shop. The shop is selling helmets and their sign read "How large is your health insurance deductible? Buy a helmet!" They're saying to potential helmet-buyers: "You are on the hook for part of the cost if you hit a tree and have a head injury." Notably, however, you're not on the hook for the whole cost --- once your deductible is paid, any incremental costs are paid by the insurer.

Because consumers don't pay the full cost, they don't shop around aggressively for low-cost care. We don't haggle for medical care the way we do for a car. (And insurance isn't the only reason for this lack of haggling --- Health care is credence good, which means it's hard for consumers to even assess quality.)

So is there any haggling in this market? Any attempt to find low-cost providers? There is, and it happens between your employer (assuming you have employer-provided care) and some HMOs. Think of an employer negotiating with a bunch of insurers. The employer wants to get a good deal, and the HMOs compete by trying to buy low cost care from providers, packaging that care with insurance, and selling it to employers. One way the HMO can get a competitive edge is to negotiate lower rates from doctors --- this is a force that helps control health care costs.

Essentially, the current system uses the profit motive to contain costs in the following way: HMOs are allowed to keep any profits they earn by negotiating for lower-cost care with health-care providers. What keeps those profits from getting too big? Competition from other HMOs. What keeps HMOs from completely ignoring the quality of care? Again, competition from other HMOs. If employers look for the best quality care for employees at the lowest possible cost, then the current system at least has some competition-based mechanisms that pushes things in that direction.

Single-payer relies on the government, not markets, to find the balance between quality and cost.

Now, before you completely flame me for writing something nice about HMOs, note that I'm not saying that the current system is the best we can do, and I'm not saying socialized medicine would be worse than the current system. But I am saying that the big question mark for socialized health care is finding a means for appropriately matching up quality and cost. The current system isn't ideal by any means, but there is at least a profit-motive-based mechanism (an imperfect one, to be sure) to get health-care costs under control.

Read the last couple paragraphs of the Gruber article, for some hints on what the big drivers of health-care inflation have been.

All this is a bit moot anyway, since most Americans are happy with the insurance they have. Read Gruber's discussions of the overinsured and the underinsured in our country on this. As a result, it seems reform will be incremental, along the lines of the Massachusetts plan.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Old Friends and Taxing CEOs

One of the cool things about the internet is that people can find you. I have friends who don't want to be found --- something about a crazy ex-girlfriend? --- but I don't mind it.

Anyway, this week I got two e-mails about this blog from old friends. One was from a Kellogg MBA who took a couple of classes from me a few years back. She's now working for a large global consulting firm. I was thrilled to get her mail --- and also thrilled to know that somebody is actually reading some of what I write here. If there are other Kellogg MBAs out there in cyberspace, come on out of the woodwork. Let me know what you're up to.

She was wondering if I had any thoughts about this article from the NYT.

After the small fortune she paid to Kellogg, I figured I should probably answer one more question from her. (Utah students: You get zero extra questions... jk.)

So here are a few thoughts:

(1) I'm not a fan of caps on pay. Super smart people have lots of opportunities. They're going to make scads of money one way or another. Do we want them to make their money working as "consultants" to the banking industry, where they can charge whatever fee they like? Or do we want them to be employees, where their fortunes can depend a bit more on how the firm does? I think the latter is better, but the pay caps will push people to the former. (I do think we should be limiting payments to owners --- that is, limiting dividend payments --- for bailout banks.)

(2) Is the Obama administration thinking about this? I am 100% certain they are. How am I so sure? Austan Goolsbee, an economist from the U of Chicago GSB who's on the President's Council of Economic Advisors, is one of the leading experts on taxing CEO pay. Here's a link to a paper of his on this.

(3) What Goolsbee found in his research was that CEO labor supply seems to be pretty inelastic. If you think back to how taxes affect economic activity, a lot depends on how elastic --- that is, how price sensitive --- demand and supply are. If demand and supply are elastic, then taxes can cause buyers and sellers to choose not to transact. The tax increases the price buyers pay and reduces the price sellers get... So if buyers and sellers are sensitive to price, this government interference will lead to reduced buying and selling. If demand and supply are inelastic, then the price doesn't matter much to the buyers and sellers. They're so eager to trade that even the tax doesn't deter them.

When the Republicans talk about how taxes will hurt economic activity, they're essentially arguing that demand and supply are elastic. This is for sure true in many markets, but not all.

Putting this in the CEO labor market context, if sellers (that is, CEOs) are price sensitive and their wages are taxed more heavily, then you might imagine them working less. A CEO might think "Well, I used to keep 70 cents of every dollar I earned, and now I keep 60. So I'll work less." If this were true, you might think that the pre-tax level of pay would go down after a tax increase.

But this isn't what seems to have happened in Goolsbee's data. CEO pay went up in the year before the tax increase and down in the year after. CEOs seem to have found ways to shift a little pay from the future to the present. But then pay went up on pretty much exactly the same trend as before.

So --- I think the advice the President is getting on taxing the rich is this: "Probably it won't cause the rich to work much less."

Let's see in the upcoming State of the Union address if Obama has anything to say about this.